How to Critique an Article?
If you are given an assignment to critique an article, there are important elements to include in your critique. They do not all have to be included in the critique; however, you should attempt to get as many in as possible. A critique is very different from a summary, but a critique should include a short summary because the reader needs to know what is being critiqued.
What is a Critique
A critique is a form of an argumentative/persuasive essay. Critiques involve analyzing an article for the quality of writing, argument, and overall effect. When you critique an essay, you will need to understand the purpose of the article and the sources that were used to create the piece. You can critique the sources to show whether or not the article is based on good research. Obviously, if the article has faulty research, that is one of the best ways to discount the facts and purpose of the article.
Every article should include an introduction and thesis statement. Once that is completed, you should begin the meat of the essay summary of the article. This summary should be no longer than a paragraph. It should include just the basic facts about the article and the purpose of the article. This is to help the reader understand what the article is about before you begin to critique it.
No Insults, Just Critiques
The next step in the critique process is to address the quality of the research and the experiments that were conducted. You do not want to insult the researchers, but you want to address any mistakes they might have made and whether or not the experiment was conducted in appropriate conditions. When you write this part of the critique, it is vital to be extremely well organized. You do not want to float willy-nilly to different aspects of the article, but to move through the critique one step at a time.
Keep it Neat
Once you have covered all of the points that you need to critique, you will then begin your conclusion. Like every conclusion, you should restate your thesis statement and review the important aspects of the critique. Be sure to end the article with a wrap-up that feels complete.
Of course, it is always vital to proofread, edit, and revise so your critique is free of errors. You should also be sure that you have effectively critiqued and not insulted the authors of the article.